Modular construction has a credibility problem in multifamily, and the industry has earned it. Each wave promised faster delivery, lower costs, and factory-grade quality. Too many ended with owners and developers absorbing the risk when manufacturers built factories that demand couldn’t keep up with, underestimated logistics, or failed outright. Katerra’s 2021 collapse, though the company was never a pure modular builder, became shorthand for the whole offsite category, and many development teams have since treated modular as a method worth watching from a distance rather than one worth underwriting.
That posture is getting harder to justify. The 21st Century ROAD to Housing Act, enacted in July, defines modular homes in federal law and directs HUD to examine the front-loaded draw structure that has long made modular projects difficult to finance through FHA, with a report due next summer and rulemaking to follow. At the same time, developers like Greystar and SoLa Impact have moved past pilot projects into repeat production at their own factories, and major general contractors including JE Dunn, Turner, and Boldt have launched dedicated offsite manufacturing arms. The result is a sector backed by better-capitalized players with more at stake than the startups that defined the last cycle.
None of this makes modular the right fit for every portfolio. Any financing changes under the law will come through FHA rulemaking that won’t begin until late 2027 at the earliest. And transportation distances, code variation, and labor dynamics still constrain where and how modular can work. This report examines what distinguishes the current modular cycle from past ones, offers a framework for evaluating potential manufacturing partners informed by McKinsey’s research on modular economics, and outlines the practical steps technology and operations leaders can take now to decide whether, and where, modular belongs in their firm’s development strategy.
Why this modular cycle looks different
Three forces distinguish the current environment from the boom-and-bust modular cycles multifamily operators have watched before.
The 21st Century ROAD to Housing Act begins to address several financing and definitional rules that have made modular hard to underwrite. Section 302, the Modular Housing Production Act, requires HUD to review FHA construction financing programs for barriers to modular methods, publish findings by July 2027, and begin rulemaking within 120 days of that report to examine alternative draw schedules. This directly addresses the front-loaded cost structure that makes modular difficult to finance. Unlike stick-built construction, where costs accrue roughly in step with site progress, modular requires finalizing and paying for design, engineering, and material decisions long before a module leaves the factory. The section also defines modular homes for the purposes of these provisions.
Section 303 raises loan limits under FHA’s Title I manufactured housing and property-improvement programs, adds accessory dwelling unit construction as an eligible use of property-improvement loans, and directs a study on the cost-effectiveness of off-site construction. Separately, Section 301 allows manufactured homes to be built with or without a permanent chassis, a change intended to lower costs and open up design options such as multi-story homes.
The changes treat manufactured and modular housing as related forms of “offsite construction housing,” though the two remain legally distinct. Manufactured homes are built to the national HUD Code, modular homes to state and local codes, and modular projects are already financed through conventional construction loans rather than chattel financing. The law appropriates no new money and authorizes almost none, so agencies must conduct their reviews and rulemaking within existing budgets. Its practical impact on underwriting will phase in over the next several years, and some directives may stall without dedicated funding.
A maturing builder base is de-risking modular’s operational side. Resia, Greystar, and SoLa Impact offer the clearest public evidence that modular can now be executed reliably at scale in multifamily. Greystar’s Ltd. brand, launched in May 2023 and built around its wholly owned modular subsidiary Modern Living Solutions, targets workforce renters with rents capped at the greater of 3% or trailing CPI growth, priced below conventional new construction. SoLa Impact, working through its affiliated modular manufacturer Model/Z, has completed 24 affordable and workforce housing projects since shifting to ground-up construction in 2019. In 2023, it determined that modular was the only way to scale its efforts, standardizing on steel-based systems because steel resists warping, water damage, and pest issues that complicate long-term lifecycle costs in high-turnover multifamily settings. SoLa has brought build timelines down from a 24-month baseline toward a 12-month goal. These are not pilot projects. They represent repeat production runs across multiple properties, the operational pattern that determines whether modular delivers on its cost and schedule promises.
Contractor and materials-supplier entry signals a thickening supply chain. JE Dunn launched Form Off-Site Solutions in April 2026, joining Turner Construction’s xPL Offsite and Boldt’s Bildt as general contractors building dedicated offsite manufacturing arms rather than treating modular as a subcontracted specialty. CertainTeed’s panelized One Precision Assemblies system, which delivers precision-engineered floor, wall, and roof panels rather than full volumetric modules, launched in 2023 across the Northeast, Midwest, and Mid-Atlantic, expanded into the Southeast in 2025, and was available in 25 states as of early 2026. The company is projecting more than 300% growth in the year ahead. A thickening supply chain of contractors and materials manufacturers plausibly reduces the single-point-of-failure risk that made the Katerra collapse so damaging to the broader modular ecosystem, though that remains an inference from the pattern of independent entrants rather than a claim any of these sources make directly.
A framework for evaluating a modular partner
McKinsey’s database of more than 700 modular construction companies across more than 50 countries points to three traits that successful companies tend to share: a building system at the core, control of the value chain, and focused scaling. Those traits offer a useful starting point for multifamily operators evaluating a potential modular partner.
Value chain control. McKinsey’s data shows that companies controlling both manufacturing and assembly post meaningfully higher margins, averaging 15% to 20% EBITDA, compared with roughly 5% for companies that handle only manufacturing. For an operator evaluating a modular partner, that raises a due diligence question. Does the manufacturer also control assembly and installation, or does that handoff go through a separate general contractor with different incentives and quality standards? If it’s the latter, how closely do the two work together? A fragmented value chain can reintroduce the coordination risk offsite construction is meant to reduce.
Building system maturity. McKinsey defines a building system as the rules, processes, and components that govern how a modular building is designed, manufactured, transported, and assembled, including which design changes are and aren’t allowed. It typically centers on a single structural material, such as steel, timber, or concrete. In McKinsey’s view, successful modular companies invest heavily in developing a robust system up front, one that allows customization within its rules, and then keep refining it based on lessons from completed projects. The firm also advises proving a system on a few projects before scaling to many.
For operators evaluating a partner, that translates into a practical due diligence question. How many times has a given building system been deployed, in what geographies, and how much design flexibility does it retain across those deployments? A system with a track record of repeat deployment likely carries less execution risk than one being reworked substantially for a first-time client, even if the latter looks more tailored to a specific site.
Focused scaling and building-type fit. McKinsey’s data suggest modular companies are more profitable when building specialized asset types such as hospitality and healthcare than when focused on single-family or multiunit residential. McKinsey attributes this to higher per-square-meter costs in specialized buildings, which give the factory environment more room to add value, and possibly to less competition in those segments.
For garden-style or mid-rise multifamily, operators may be better served weighting schedule and cost-certainty benefits over dramatic unit-cost savings. Operators should also confirm that a manufacturer has stable, committed demand for its factory rather than building capacity speculatively ahead of orders. McKinsey links many of the modular industry’s recent shortcomings to unfocused scaling, including large factories built without enough demand to fill them. Katerra’s 2021 collapse is the best-known U.S. example. The company expanded capacity and integrated nearly every step of the process before proving its model on a narrower footprint.
The fine print on modular fit
The framework above is necessary but not sufficient, because several operational realities complicate its application in a live multifamily development pipeline.
Even if HUD revises FHA draw schedules under the ROAD Act, which directs the agency to examine barriers to modular construction financing, modular projects will still demand more up-front commitment than stick-built ones. Design and engineering decisions must be locked before factory production begins, leaving far less room to revise mid-project. For development teams used to iterating on unit mix or finish packages late in a project’s timeline, that’s one of the hardest adjustments to make.
Transportation logistics constrain site selection more than most operators expect. Industry rules of thumb for the maximum practical factory-to-site distance generally range from about 250 to 500 miles, though some manufacturers with their own logistics operations ship considerably farther. That means you need to evaluate portfolio geography and factory location together, not as independent variables. Code approvals add another layer. In many states, a state modular program reviews the units themselves while local officials review the foundation, utilities, and site work. A first project in a new jurisdiction can be complex to navigate, particularly where local reviewers haven’t seen modular before. Developers who build repeatedly in the same jurisdiction often report smoother reviews as officials become familiar with the process.
Labor dynamics also cut both ways. In Northern California, the regional carpenters union has embraced modular, organizing factory workers at plants like Factory_OS. San Francisco’s Building and Construction Trades Council, by contrast, has opposed modular projects, in part because factory agreements let carpenters do work traditionally performed by electricians, plumbers, and other trades. The same rift has played out statewide in fights over labor standards in housing legislation. Operators building across multiple states should expect these dynamics to vary meaningfully by market, mattering most where construction union density is high. They should factor labor relations into site and partner selection alongside the more visible cost and schedule variables.
Turning evaluation into a modular strategy
Evaluating a partner against the framework above is a necessary first step, but it alone does not produce a modular strategy. The following five actions translate that evaluation into an operational plan a technology or operations team could begin executing this quarter.
Map portfolio geography against factory locations before evaluating specific modular partners. Transportation economics typically degrade beyond a few hundred miles, with most industry estimates putting the practical limit around 400 to 500. So filter the shortlist of viable manufacturers by proximity to active or planned development sites. Then verify whether any farther-flung candidates have the logistics capacity to ship economically beyond that range.
Ask prospective manufacturers for production utilization and backlog data, not just capability claims. A factory with steady, high utilization and forward-booked repeat clients generally carries less execution risk than one with impressive specifications but a thin order book. Just confirm it has production slots available on your timeline. As McKinsey’s research and Katerra’s collapse show, capacity built without matching demand has driven much of the modular industry’s recent underperformance.
Restructure internal financing and design-approval workflows to front-load decision-making. Development teams should lock in unit mix, finish selection, and MEP specifications, and secure permits, much earlier than stick-built workflows require, since those decisions must be final before factory production begins.
Pilot in a single jurisdiction before scaling across markets. McKinsey advises modular companies to prove their approach on a few projects in one geography before expanding. The same logic applies to operators. Plan a first modular deployment as a deliberate market-entry investment rather than a one-off test, and budget its timeline for the extra scrutiny that comes with local officials, contractors, and the development team all working through modular for the first time. Repeat projects in the same jurisdiction should benefit from that familiarity.
Track the ROAD Act’s implementation timeline directly rather than assuming immediate financing relief. Section 302 directs HUD to study barriers to modular construction financing and then start a rulemaking. It doesn’t change FHA programs on its own. HUD’s report is due within a year of enactment, around July 2027, with a rulemaking to begin within 120 days after that. Technology and finance leadership at operators using FHA construction financing should monitor both milestones to understand when and how those programs will actually change.
Where modular stands now
Modular construction in multifamily is neither the imminent industry transformation its most enthusiastic advocates describe nor the discredited relic that skepticism after Katerra’s 2021 collapse might suggest. The current moment is defined by the early stages of easing the financing barriers that have made modular difficult to underwrite, paired with a set of builders that now have multi-year production records. Even established producers remain exposed to demand gaps. Harbinger Production, formerly Factory_OS, warned in early 2026 that it might close its Vallejo factory despite delivering roughly 4,000 units since 2017.
Operators evaluating modular today can look at production histories that didn’t exist during the previous modular cycle. Value chain control, building system maturity, and focused scaling give technology and operations leadership a concrete basis for distinguishing a durable modular partner from one repeating last cycle’s mistakes.
The portfolios that benefit most will likely be those that treat modular as a deliberate, geography-specific capability built over several projects rather than a one-time procurement decision, with internal financing and design workflows aligned to the method’s front-loaded structure rather than forcing modular into processes built for stick-built construction. Operators who make that adjustment now, while the ROAD Act’s modular financing provisions are still working through HUD review and rulemaking, will be better positioned if and when those provisions translate into materially easier modular financing.
– Nick Pipitone





